I forgot there are modern short-cuts.Ronning's Ghost wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:50 pmI meant better than when you decided you needed to re-tool or rebuild. Addressing this would take more scholarship than I am willing to undertake at the moment; the sample size is huge, and we'd need to agree on standards for "minimally competent" and "average luck".UWSaint wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:02 pmI just don't see evidence of this being the "average" result, unless you are measuring from the lowest ebb, which by definition has improvements.Ronning's Ghost wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:55 pm At least with a re-build, with minimally competent management, and just average luck, four to five seasons later, you should be stronger than when you went in.
"For NHL teams that entered a re-build since 1995, what proportion had better records than when they started 5 seasons after the re-build started?"
Chat GTP:
There is a particularly relevant study that gets remarkably close to answering your question.
1. A 2026 study of 26 NHL rebuilds
Nick Iacoban's January 2026 study, The Anatomy of an NHL Rebuild: What Actually Creates a Champion?, identified 26 rebuilds beginning between 2008 and 2023.
It examined each team's regular-season standings points from five seasons before the rebuild through eight seasons afterward.
Sports Analytics Group at Berkeley
Its aggregate results are:
Average NHL standings points around a rebuild
26 rebuilds identified in the Berkeley study. T0 is the starting season.
Average standings points
T−5 92
T−4 88
T−3 86
T−2 87
T−1 85
T0 65
T+1 71
T+2 75
T+3 81
T+4 83
T+5 83
T+6 92
T+7 93
T+8 95
The average team:
• Had 65 points in its rebuild-starting season.
• Had 83 points five seasons later.
• Improved by 18 standings points, approximately 28%.
That is encouraging evidence for rebuilding.
However, an average improvement does not tell us what proportion of the 26 individual teams improved. A handful of substantial improvements could lift the average even if many teams did not improve.
2. Why this isn't quite your answer
There are three qualifications:
1. The Berkeley study uses a standings-based definition of a rebuild, rather than exclusively the transaction and media-based definition we've been using. {I started the conversation with other re-build questions, below}
2. Its 26 observations include repeated rebuilds by the same franchises, such as Buffalo and Edmonton.
3. The number of teams with an observable fifth post-rebuild season is smaller than 26, because the sample includes rebuilds beginning as recently as 2023.
A second study by Daily Faceoff identifies 20 completed modern rebuilds, using a different definition: at least two bottom-ten finishes, including one bottom-eight finish, within three seasons. It reports an average rebuild duration of 8.5 years.
Gemini:
No public database tracks every post-1995 NHL rebuild under that exact "Year 5 vs. Year 0" record comparison. However, sports analytics research from The Athletic and Daily Faceoff shows that roughly 60% to 75% of rebuilding NHL teams improve their regular-season record by Year 5, largely because Year 0 represents a steep bottoming-out baseline.
Despite having a better record than when they started, fewer than 25% of modern NHL rebuilds actually reach sustained playoff contention by Year 5, as the average successful rebuild takes 8.5 to 10.4 years to mature.
Why Year 5 Shows Mixed Results
How a team looks five seasons into a rebuild depends heavily on how "Year 0" is defined and where the franchise sits in the NHL's multi-stage development cycle.
• Low Baseline Effect. Most rebuilds officially begin after a team sells off veterans and finishes in the bottom 10 of the league. Because Year 0 typically sits around 60 to 75 standings points, merely graduating a few first-round draft picks to the NHL roster by Year 5 is usually enough to lift a team to 80–88 points—producing a better record without making them a contender. [1, 2]
• The NHL Development Lag. Unlike the NBA or NFL, where top draft picks immediately transform a roster, NHL prospects require two to three years in junior, college, or minor leagues before making an impact. According to The Athletic's multi-decade rebuild analysis, teams spend their first three to five years strictly in an "accumulation" phase before entering a "development" phase characterized by 10-point seasonal jumps. [1, 2]
I wanted to address UWSaint's question first in this post, but as I said, I actually started with other questions. I was getting the impression that the site did not love huge posts, so I'll present those in a follow-up post.

