Page 1 of 1
AIs compare re-builds and re-tools
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:08 am
by Ronning's Ghost
Moved from the 'Worst Canucks teams ever' topic.
Ronning's Ghost wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:50 pm
UWSaint wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:02 pm
Ronning's Ghost wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:55 pm
At least with a re-build, with minimally competent management, and just average luck, four to five seasons later, you should be stronger than when you went in.
I just don't see evidence of this being the "average" result, unless you are measuring from the lowest ebb, which by definition has improvements.
I meant better than when you decided you needed to re-tool or rebuild.
Addressing this would take more scholarship than I am willing to undertake at the moment; the sample size is huge, and we'd need to agree on standards for "minimally competent" and "average luck".
I forgot there are modern short-cuts.
"For NHL teams that entered a re-build since 1995, what proportion had better records than when they started 5 seasons after the re-build started?"
Chat GTP:
There is a particularly relevant study that gets remarkably close to answering your question.
1. A 2026 study of 26 NHL rebuilds
Nick Iacoban's January 2026 study, The Anatomy of an NHL Rebuild: What Actually Creates a Champion?, identified 26 rebuilds beginning between 2008 and 2023.
It examined each team's regular-season standings points from five seasons before the rebuild through eight seasons afterward.
Sports Analytics Group at Berkeley
Its aggregate results are:
Average NHL standings points around a rebuild
26 rebuilds identified in the Berkeley study. T0 is the starting season.
Average standings points
T−5 92
T−4 88
T−3 86
T−2 87
T−1 85
T0 65
T+1 71
T+2 75
T+3 81
T+4 83
T+5 83
T+6 92
T+7 93
T+8 95
The average team:
• Had 65 points in its rebuild-starting season.
• Had 83 points five seasons later.
• Improved by 18 standings points, approximately 28%.
That is encouraging evidence for rebuilding.
However, an average improvement does not tell us what proportion of the 26 individual teams improved. A handful of substantial improvements could lift the average even if many teams did not improve.
2. Why this isn't quite your answer
There are three qualifications:
1. The Berkeley study uses a standings-based definition of a rebuild, rather than exclusively the transaction and media-based definition
we've been using. {I started the conversation with other re-build questions, below}
2. Its 26 observations include repeated rebuilds by the same franchises, such as Buffalo and Edmonton.
3. The number of teams with an observable fifth post-rebuild season is smaller than 26, because the sample includes rebuilds beginning as recently as 2023.
A second study by Daily Faceoff identifies 20 completed modern rebuilds, using a different definition: at least two bottom-ten finishes, including one bottom-eight finish, within three seasons. It reports an average rebuild duration of 8.5 years.
Gemini:
No public database tracks every post-1995 NHL rebuild under that exact "Year 5 vs. Year 0" record comparison. However, sports analytics research from The Athletic and Daily Faceoff shows that roughly 60% to 75% of rebuilding NHL teams improve their regular-season record by Year 5, largely because Year 0 represents a steep bottoming-out baseline.
Despite having a better record than when they started, fewer than 25% of modern NHL rebuilds actually reach sustained playoff contention by Year 5, as the average successful rebuild takes 8.5 to 10.4 years to mature.
Why Year 5 Shows Mixed Results
How a team looks five seasons into a rebuild depends heavily on how "Year 0" is defined and where the franchise sits in the NHL's multi-stage development cycle.
• Low Baseline Effect. Most rebuilds officially begin after a team sells off veterans and finishes in the bottom 10 of the league. Because Year 0 typically sits around 60 to 75 standings points, merely graduating a few first-round draft picks to the NHL roster by Year 5 is usually enough to lift a team to 80–88 points—producing a better record without making them a contender. [1, 2]
• The NHL Development Lag. Unlike the NBA or NFL, where top draft picks immediately transform a roster, NHL prospects require two to three years in junior, college, or minor leagues before making an impact. According to The Athletic's multi-decade rebuild analysis, teams spend their first three to five years strictly in an "accumulation" phase before entering a "development" phase characterized by 10-point seasonal jumps. [1, 2]
I wanted to address UWSaint's question first in this post, but as I said, I actually started with other questions. I was getting the impression that the site did not love huge posts, so I'll present those in a follow-up post.
Re: AIs compare re-builds and re-tools
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:40 am
by Ronning's Ghost
In the context of North American professional sport, compare the relative success rates of a re-tool on the fly versus a complete tear-down and re-build. If you don’t find those terms used by the clubs or their press, a re-tool on the fly is an attempt to the team to extend or quickly refresh their competitive window, and is usually characterized by trading away later maturing assets in exchange for earlier maturing assets (e.g. trading away draft picks to get minor league prospects, or prospects to get major league ready players), and signing free agents in their prime to medium or long-term contracts, whereas a tear-down and re-build does the opposite, acknowledging that short term success is unlikely, and so attempting to maximize team performance in future seasons, and thus trading away players for draft picks or minor league prospects, and signing late career free agents to short-term contracts as role models.
For the purpose of this analysis, define success as either
1) a league championship within 10 seasons of starting the re-tool or re-build
Or
2) four out of any five consecutive seasons finishing in the top quintile of the regular season within 10 seasons of starting the re-tool or re-build.
(I took this as an indication of a competitive window, even if no championship is won.)
Chat GTP is well-named, giving me a very chatty answer. Some excerpts:
1. What the available evidence tells us
The strongest directly relevant evidence I found comes from the NHL. Evidence from the other leagues is more fragmented, and there is no established cross-league study that calculates success using both of your ten-year criteria.
NHL: Rebuilds have a strong historical record, but are far from guaranteed
A 2025 analysis by Daily Faceoff, Do Rebuilds Actually Work in the NHL?, examined 20 recent NHL rebuilds whose competitive peaks fell between 2006 and 2025.
Its headline findings were:
• 10 of the 20 rebuilds produced at least one Stanley Cup.
• Those rebuilds accounted for 17 Stanley Cup championships during the salary-cap era.
• Only two of the 20 failed to produce what the authors considered a competitive team.
• Some of the non-championship successes included Edmonton's Stanley Cup Final appearances, the Islanders' multiple Conference Final appearances, and Toronto's extended playoff presence.
Results of the 20 NHL rebuilds
Daily Faceoff's classification of recent rebuilds.
teams
Won at least one Cup 10
No Cup, but competitive 8
Failed to become competitive 2
There is an important qualification: this isn't a randomly selected sample of all rebuilding teams. The analysis identifies rebuilds retrospectively, and its definition of success is more generous than your definition. Nevertheless, it provides a useful indication that rebuilding can produce substantial competitive returns.
There are also some important counterexamples:
• Edmonton Oilers: Multiple high draft selections and a lengthy rebuilding process before becoming a genuine championship contender.
• Buffalo Sabres: A particularly prominent example of a tear-down that failed to produce a timely return to competitiveness.
• Toronto Maple leaves: Their rebuilding strategy eventually produced a strong regular-season team, although championship success remained elusive.
• Detroit Red Wings: A prolonged rebuilding process following the end of their remarkable playoff streak.
Sportsnet's examination of rebuilding teams highlights how unpredictable the process can be, even when a team accumulates high draft selections.
NHL: Retooling can work, but the evidence is less systematic
Washington is an interesting example. Rather than dismantling its roster as its championship core aged, the Capitals acquired younger, NHL-ready players while retaining important veterans.
The organization explicitly described the approach as retooling rather than rebuilding. NHL reporting highlighted acquisitions including Pierre-Luc Dubois and Jakob Chychrun, alongside the development of younger players already in the organization.
NHL
Other relevant examples include:
• Winnipeg Jets: Retained core players Mark Scheifele and Connor Hellebuyck while moving on from other veterans and acquiring players who could contribute immediately.
• Pittsburgh Penguins: Have repeatedly attempted to refresh their supporting roster around Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang.
• Boston Bruins: Have used a combination of veteran departures, younger roster players and retained core talent to transition away from their previous competitive group.
…
Why rebuilds sometimes fail
I think there are four particularly important failure mechanisms.
1. Draft capital is not equivalent to talent.
Having more draft picks increases the number of opportunities to find good players, but it doesn't guarantee that the selections will become elite professionals. The NBA research discussed above is particularly relevant here.
2. Rebuilding can become self-perpetuating.
A team acquires young players, those players fail to develop as expected, the management group changes, and the new management group begins another rebuilding process.
Buffalo's experience in the NHL illustrates this problem.
3. A collection of good young players is not necessarily a championship team.
Teams need to assemble a balanced roster, with the right combination of positional strengths, experience, leadership and complementary skills.
4. The organization has to remain competent throughout the process.
Scouting, player development, coaching and management quality matter enormously. Accumulating draft picks without the organizational capacity to convert them into professional talent is not a strategy.
The evidence from the NBA draft study and Baseball America's examination of successful and unsuccessful MLB rebuilds supports these concerns
A few more clarifications got us to:
Clear examples and their outcomes
These are the examples I can substantiate most confidently from the historical accounts retrieved. They are not being presented as an exhaustive list of every qualifying NHL episode.
Sorry, I don't have the skills to make the tables tidy, but I trust you can follow it, anyway.
Rebuilds
Franchise Start First Cup following start Within 10 seasons?
Pittsburgh 2001 2009 Yes
Chicago 2002 2010 Yes
Washington 2003 2018 No
Carolina 2003 2006 Yes
Tampa Bay 2007 2020 No
Colorado 2011 2022 No
Toronto 2008 None through 2026 No
Edmonton 2010 None through 2026 No
Buffalo 2013 None through 2026 No
The table demonstrates why it is important to distinguish a ten-year championship result from eventual success. Washington and Tampa eventually won, but not within the ten-season period measured from the start dates above.
Re-tools
Franchise Approximate start Subsequent championship Assessment
Philadelphia 1994–95 None Reached 1997 Final
Detroit 2001–02 2002 Successful
Pittsburgh 2015 2016, 2017 Successful
St. Louis 2018 2019 Successful
Florida 2022 2024, 2025 Successful
The rationale for these classifications:
• Philadelphia: substantial reconstruction of the defence and goaltending while retaining Lindros and the emerging offensive core.
Philadelphia Flyers
• Detroit: major veteran additions around an established championship-calibre roster.
• Pittsburgh: explicitly described as a retool by retrospective coverage, retaining its central stars while refreshing its supporting roster.
On Tap Sports Net
• St. Louis: described as a retool rather than a full teardown.
On Tap Sports Net
• Florida: major roster renovation, retaining the competitive foundation while making substantial acquisitions. Its classification is less definitive, so I would flag it rather than treat it as an unquestionable example.
The Pittsburgh and St. Louis results are particularly interesting: they demonstrate that a retool can produce a championship without first enduring several seasons of deliberate non-competitiveness.
The results we can actually establish
There are some meaningful observations from the identified examples.
• The classic rebuilds in Pittsburgh, Chicago and Carolina produced championships within ten seasons.
• Washington, Tampa Bay and Colorado produced championships, but outside the ten-season limit from the selected start dates.
• Pittsburgh's 2015 retool produced two consecutive championships.
• St. Louis's 2018 retool produced a championship the following season.
• Florida's 2022 roster renovation produced consecutive championships in 2024 and 2025, subject to the classification qualification above.
Gemini's take was:
Across the four major North American professional sports leagues (NHL, NBA, MLB, and NFL), complete tear-downs and rebuilds achieve a higher rate of championship and sustained top-quintile success within a 10-year window than re-tools on the fly, provided the franchise already lacks elite foundational talent. However, re-tools on the fly succeed at a higher rate when a team already possesses a generational superstar or elite core, largely because they avoid the severe variance and timeline delays of draft lotteries.
Because no single academic study tracks all four leagues simultaneously under your exact 10-year, two-part success rubric, sports analytics research across individual leagues reveals clear patterns in how both strategies perform against those benchmarks.
Comparison by Success Criteria
Tear-Down & Rebuild
Championship Rate (Within 10 Years): Higher. In the NHL salary-cap era, 17 of 20 recent Stanley Cup champions were built via multi-year rebuilds. Average time to a title is 8.5 to 10.4 years, putting successful rebuilds right on the edge of the 10-year cutoff.
Top-Quintile Consistency (4 of 5 Years): Higher ceiling, delayed start. Once a rebuild hits, teams often enter a 5-to-10-year window averaging top-five league finishes.
Primary Failure Mode: Perpetual basement. Missing on top draft picks or lacking player development traps franchises in decade-long droughts (e.g., Buffalo Sabres, Sacramento Kings).
Re-Tool on the Fly
Championship Rate (Within 10 Years): Lower. Re-tools rarely generate enough top-end talent to win a title unless an MVP-caliber player is already on the roster.
Top-Quintile Consistency (4 of 5 Years): Moderate ceiling, immediate start. Frequently produces perennial playoff teams (top 30%–50%), but rarely sustains top-20% (top-quintile) dominance.
Primary Failure Mode: "Mushy middle." Trading future picks for veteran help caps the roster's ceiling, leaving the team too good for top draft picks but not good enough to contend.
League-by-League Dynamics
Structural differences in salary caps, draft rules, and roster sizes heavily dictate which strategy meets your 10-year criteria in each sport.
• NBA (Strongest Advantage for Tear-Downs). Basketball is driven by single-player impact, where a top-five player disproportionately determines top-quintile finishes and titles. Because prime superstars rarely hit open free agency without demanding specific big-market destinations, small- and mid-market teams rely heavily on top-five draft picks to acquire franchise cornerstones. [1]
• NHL (High Championship Conversion, Tight 10-Year Timeline). Studies from The Athletic and Daily Faceoff show that rebuilding is the dominant path to a Stanley Cup. However, NHL prospects take longer to mature than NBA or NFL rookies. Because the average successful NHL rebuild takes roughly 8.5 to 10.4 years from its first cornerstone draft pick to a championship, many successful NHL rebuilds barely clear a strict 10-year window. [1, 2, 3]
• MLB (High Variance, Farm-System Dependent). Baseball rebuilds (such as the Houston Astros and Chicago Cubs in the 2010s) frequently meet both the championship and top-quintile criteria within 7 to 10 years because shedding payroll allows teams to stockpile international bonus pool money and top draft picks. Conversely, large-market franchises (like the Los Angeles Dodgers or New York Yankees) successfully re-tool on the fly by using financial muscle to absorb prime free agents while protecting top minor-league talent.
• NFL (Fastest Turnaround for Both Strategies). Hard salary caps, non-guaranteed contracts, and the immediate impact of college draftees allow NFL teams to execute complete tear-downs in just 2 to 4 years. At the same time, landing an elite quarterback allows an NFL franchise to re-tool on the fly indefinitely through aggressive free agency and draft-pick trades (such as the Los Angeles Rams' "F them picks" era).
Key Takeaways on Execution
• Pre-Existing Core Determines Viability. As noted in sports management analyses from Sportsnet and the Sports Analytics Group at Berkeley, a re-tool only meets top-quintile or championship standards when a team is refreshing support pieces around a proven superstar. Attempting a re-tool without an elite core almost always fails both criteria.
• The "10-Year" Trap for Rebuilds. While tear-downs produce far more champions than re-tools, starting the clock on Day 1 of the teardown penalizes sports with slow developmental curves (NHL and MLB). A team that spends 4 years at the bottom and 3 years climbing the standings only has 3 seasons left in a 10-year window to satisfy a "4-of-5 years in the top quintile" benchmark.
Re: AIs compare re-builds and re-tools
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:51 am
by Ronning's Ghost
Let’s reverse the perspective. For every Stanley Cup Champion, from 2006 to 2025, identify and tabulate whether it is the result of a re-tool or a rebuild when the strategies meet our established criteria, or are described that was by either the clubs themselves or the hockey media. If the team does not clearly fall into either category, label it “other”.
Chat GTP:
Cup year Champion Classification Explanation
2006 Carolina Hurricanes Re-tool Rapid roster renovation, adding NHL-ready veterans around an emerging core.
2007 Anaheim Ducks Other Drafted talent supplemented by major acquisitions, notably Chris Pronger and Scott Niedermayer. No sufficiently clear rebuild or re-tool episode.
2008 Detroit Red Wings Other Maintained an established elite team. Hossa and other additions strengthened an already championship-calibre roster.
2009 Pittsburgh Penguins Rebuild Earlier dismantling and accumulation of draft talent produced Crosby, Malkin and the championship core.
2010 Chicago Blackhawks Rebuild Deliberate rebuilding through several strong draft classes, particularly Toews and Kane.
2011 Boston Bruins Other Combination of homegrown talent, free-agent signings and trades. No sufficiently distinct qualifying strategy.
2012 Los Angeles Kings Rebuild Dean Lombardi's documented rebuilding programme, including high draft selections and subsequent roster construction.
2013 Chicago Blackhawks Rebuild Continuation of the rebuild that produced the 2010 championship.
2014 Los Angeles Kings Rebuild Continuation of the same rebuilding programme.
2015 Chicago Blackhawks Rebuild Continuation of the same rebuilding programme.
2016 Pittsburgh Penguins Re-tool Explicit roster re-tool under Jim Rutherford while retaining Crosby, Malkin and Letang.
2017 Pittsburgh Penguins Re-tool Continuation of the 2016 re-tool, with relatively minor further changes.
2018 Washington Capitals Re-tool Retained the Ovechkin-led competitive core and added NHL-ready talent through trades and free agency.
2019 St. Louis Blues Re-tool Retained the competitive foundation while acquiring established contributors, notably Ryan O'Reilly and Brayden Schenn.
2020 Tampa Bay Lightning Rebuild The result of the earlier rebuild built around Stamkos, Hedman and subsequently drafted talent.
2021 Tampa Bay Lightning Rebuild Continuation of the same rebuilding programme.
2022 Colorado Avalanche Rebuild Joe Sakic's documented rebuilding of Colorado following several non-playoff seasons.
2023 Vegas Golden Knights Other Expansion franchise.
2024 Florida Panthers Re-tool Retained the Barkov-led foundation while making major acquisitions to turn the team into a championship contender.
2025 Florida Panthers Re-tool Continuation of the 2024 re-tool
I'm sure I made a neat table here once, but it's too late in the evening for me to figure out how, now. If anyone has a link to a tutorial (ideally text, not video) I'll undertake to read it before I try to post any tabulated information again.
Re: AIs compare re-builds and re-tools
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:10 am
by Cornuck
Ok - that's a fairly deep analysis, and somewhat comforting. <insert 'So you're saying there's a chance' meme here>
Yes, the NHL is unique in that the draft picks usually don't make an immediate impact, so an NHL rebuild is longer than in other sports. Because of that, we don't know how our picks are going to turn out for 3 or 4 years in many cases. A team could think the rebuild is coming along nicely, but then those coveted picks never make the big step. BUT... it seems that only 2 of the 20 rebuilds completely shit the bed.
Thanks for putting that together.
Re: AIs compare re-builds and re-tools
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 10:56 am
by Ronning's Ghost
Cornuck wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:10 am
Ok - that's a fairly deep analysis, and somewhat comforting. <insert '
So you're saying there's a chance' meme here>
The only part I found discouraging was the timeline. I was thinking the return to competitiveness was 4-5 seasons away, but the typical re-build appears to take 8-12. Even allowing for the boost from the Hughes trade (and assuming a couple of those players, or the players they get for them in trade, are part of the eventually competitive team), we're still probably six seasons out. In my view, that makes the Podkolzin trade especially unfortunate.
Re: AIs compare re-builds and re-tools
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 11:41 am
by Tciso
It seems to me that we need to maximize our player value. We really do have to trade high on anyone over 27, or on an expiring UFA contract. But, as a 10 year project (8.75 years to go), we can't panic and make bad trades.
I expect Gallagher will be traded for peanuts at some point. Chytil too (maybe a 2nd if he is healthy). Either Doc or Cotter will likely go too. But, i don't see a reason to rush any of our "core 4 trade candidates". Boeser, EP40, DeBrusk or Hronek. If we can get more later, I hope we hang onto these guys. AI indicates NMCs lower trade returns, but my cheap version has no numbers. So, AI added nothing we didn't already know. But, modified NMCs don't have as much of an impact. Patience is trading our guys is going to be key.
Re: AIs compare re-builds and re-tools
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:02 pm
by UWSaint
All of this is pretty interesting, and we identified many of the issues in the other thread.
Sure, they can work, but in 5 years? Unusual.
Of course, analysis that looks at winners and works backwards doesn't answer the question about likelihood of success, and we don't have a stable denominator (teams who rebuild, teams who retool). And within those categories is plenty of room for interpretation.
Did the Penguins, for example, really rebuild in the traditional sense? It think yes, but.... They acquired ZERO extra first round picks those years. They did "tank" insofar as they traded away Jagr (who was arguably the league's best player), but they did so not because the writing was on the wall w/r/t competitiveness, but because they went bankrupt and the Capitals gave them money. The lack of competitiveness followed the lack of being able to pay players.
What made the Canucks efforts a "retool" as opposed to a rebuild were three things: (1) they said that's what they were doing, (2) the Sedins weren't traded, (3) they traded away some second rounders--including extras acquired in the tear down--for developing prospects/young NHLers instead of picks.
I think (1) was evidenced by (2) and (3) and not by shedding assets, but by free agent acquisitions that didn't require assets lost outside of the ability to weaponize cap space. The idea behind (3) was logical and if suboptimal, only by the narrowest of margins. The system was completely empty, even worse off than that Allvin and Rutherford left behind, and so they basically made the decision to restock with what might have been there but for the trades and missed picks during the Gillis era. Those second round assets used for Vey, Baertschi, and Granlund (don't count Etem, that was a 6th) didn't amount to much in hindsight, but their individual contributions were the kinds of things you usually get from 2d rounders: a bust (Vey), an underwhelming swiss army knife more useful as depth on a good team than an important player on a bad one (Granlund), and a middle six caliber winger miscast as a first line winger who's career was derailed by injury.
The elephant was always (2) -- keeping the Sedins. They were not only the most valuable assets in a trade, but keeping them tipped the scales on the question of stockpile picks or retroactively replenish a depleted system. The rebuild advocate (Linden), didn't want to move them, and so his objection really was one of style over substance, no?
The good news was that the retool FAILED entirely , which meant they got year after year of plum picks (but sadly no lottery luck) (except for Benning year one, and the Canucks did fine in drafting Boeser), and so the only effect was that when those plum picks developed, there were less second round "darts" that might have could have would have maybe possibly complemented them. A single defenseman would have made a big difference, whether that would have been drafting say, McAvoy instead of Juolevi, or drafting Andersson with a traded away second round pick. Which of course they wouldn't have done....