CanucksCorner.com Forums

Sbisa vs Garrison

RoyalDude wrote:Sbisa vs Garrison

What’s the question ?

RoyalDude wrote:Sbisa vs Garrison

13 games, 6 assists, 6 points, +4

vs

cleared waivers and toiling in the AHL

micky107 wrote:http://www.espn.com/nhl/statistics/play ... on/rookies

Not gonna lie, I had to check the rookie standings this morning too!

I missed the game last night, and was actually choked about missing it - probably the first time in 2 years that's happened.

Now I wish I had PVRed it.

I am amazed at how far this team has come in being more watchable, and a lot of that credit goes to Brock. I don't want to miss what he's going to do next.

The +/- in those stats says BB may well be a better all round player. Not to mention fewer games.

I'm hoping we see something similar in Gaudette.

Topper wrote:

RoyalDude wrote:Sbisa vs Garrison

13 games, 6 assists, 6 points, +4

vs

cleared waivers and toiling in the AHL

What’s the question ?

Bubbles "still" takes Garrison over Sbisa

RoyalDude wrote:Bubbles "still" takes Garrison over Sbisa

I’d take neither at this point. Both are grossly overpaid bottom pairing d men. Garrison was a better player here and his trade value reflected that. One guy went for a 2nd ...... refresh my memory, what did Elmer get for Sbisa ?

Blob Mckenzie wrote:

RoyalDude wrote:Bubbles "still" takes Garrison over Sbisa

I’d take neither at this point. Both are grossly overpaid bottom pairing d men. Garrison was a better player here and his trade value reflected that. One guy went for a 2nd ...... refresh my memory, what did Elmer get for Sbisa ?

Gaunce

Stalwart Luca Sbisa has the second highest ATOI for the Au Nights

Gaunce was a 2012 draft pick.He and Sbisa were both exposed in the expansion draft. He wasn’t acquired for Sbisa. Sbisa was never in the top 4 in ice time on a scabby Vancouver team. Good for him he is getting big minutes on an expansion team that is currently playing well. I don’t expect that to continue. Who would he bump out of the top 6 in Vancouver ?

Topper wrote: Stalwart Luca Sbisa has the second highest ATOI for the Au Nights

not sure what the point is here. Are you saying Benning is a moron for exposing him?

Garrison vs. Sbisa:
Garrison had 49 pts (15G) and was +13 in 128 GP for Vancouver playing 21 mins/game and was turned into a 2nd round pick.
Sbisa had 32 pts (7G) and was -4 in 199 GP, playing 18 mins/night and was given away for nothing.

lol it's okay to crawl out of Jimbo's ass for air once in a while.

Island Nucklehead wrote:

Topper wrote: Stalwart Luca Sbisa has the second highest ATOI for the Au Nights

not sure what the point is here. Are you saying Benning is a moron for exposing him?

Garrison vs. Sbisa:
Garrison had 49 pts (15G) and was +13 in 128 GP for Vancouver playing 21 mins/game and was turned into a 2nd round pick.
Sbisa had 32 pts (7G) and was -4 in 199 GP, playing 18 mins/night and was given away for nothing.

lol it's okay to crawl out of Jimbo's ass for air once in a while.

Didn't we lose Sbisa in the expansion draft?? As in EVERY team lost someone for nothing?

(Not getting in the middle, just curious how they can be compared)

The point is Garrison returned a 2nd rounder and played better as a Canuck. Sbisa was a tire fire in Vancouver for three seasons and they couldn’t even get a 7th for him. Either way they are both fine on a bottom pairing making 700k - 1.5 million. Both of them have bad contracts. A dozen good games for Sbisa doesn’t erase how poorly he has played for most of his career.

Blob Mckenzie wrote:

Topper wrote:

Island Nucklehead wrote:

Strangelove wrote:https://www.capfriendly.com/teams/goldenknights

Vegas roster with cap-hits is up...

That defence looks capable of dolling out some punishment.

STALWART

Such a stalwart they can't give him away for a 7th.

Blob Mckenzie wrote:Lol Sbisa is not a top 4 dman on any team.There will be a dozen better options for Vegas to pick from to bolster the back end.

Blob Mckenzie wrote:Teams don't use Luca Sbisa and Brandon Sutter as building blocks