Re: Worst Canucks teams ever
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 11:21 pm
They were assets that were sadly immovable. Had they been tradeable, the return would have gone a long way to rebuilding.
Sure. The whole NMC. I agree. Stop rewording what I am saying.
Jim Rutherford as senior advisor will surely bring steady level-headed wisdom to the c-suite newbs.
At the end of the day ownership was given 2 pitches...retool or rebuild and they chose to retool....Madcombinepilot wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 12:15 amSure. The whole NMC. I agree. Stop rewording what I am saying.
I am saying everything else around it was fucked. (Giving up picks, bad trades, horrible signings, etc)
I mostly agree with this, but I want to add that skilled management also matters quite a bit.rikster wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 8:22 am ...
In some ways I think rebuilds are a cop out and an admission that you don't have the skills to pull off a retool...
Either choice requires luck, lots of it no matter how skilled management is and how supportive ownership is...
...
Looking at the bottom half of the standings today is not a pretty sight for anyone pushing a rebuild to their ownership group, especially given the makeup of ownership groups and franchise value in todays world...
Here’s where I somewhat disagree with their immovability.Aaronp18 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 9:09 am The Sedin's would've waived for the right opportunity, the issue is they would have only waived if they could play together somewhere and get a chance at a Cup.
That's really the issue, and probably why I think Topper laments at their immovability.
Not a lot of teams competing for the Cup had the cap space to bring them both in without giving up significant roster pieces.
"Doomed" is too strong a word, but it was a long-shot, just by the nature of what you're trying to accomplish. I can think of few examples of success -- and I don't define success as a championship, just keeping the competitive window open longer.
yeah, a re-tool takes more skill. And
But a re-tool takes more luck. And the downside is higher. If your re-tool fails, you've wasted some competitive seasons, and started the re-build that eventually manifestly becomes necessary from a weaker position.
I don't disagree, just that the reality of getting a POH/GM and an owner to agree to take the plunge into the abiss of a rebuild is a very hard thing to do which is why most teams resist or refuse to take the leap of faith...Mëds wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 12:16 pm To rik and UW’s posts regarding the requirement of luck in a rebuild or retool…..
Both choices also require patient and hands off ownership.
If ownership is unwilling to absorb the cost of a full rebuild (and there is enough in-house talent to go forward with as develop and improve or tempting trade chips) then the retool option still requires skilled management be left alone by the owner to execute the plan.
When things were shaky here, but the team looking promising (2023-24), and retool was up for debate, there were good offers on Petey when he was refusing to sign in-season. Ownership scrapped it. The rest is history. According to what I was told recently, our suspicions about Frank being very very hands on in roster building decisions are highly accurate.
If you are committing to a rebuild, same story. Hire the management group and let them work. Don’t piss the bed after a couple of seasons, or jizz in your pants over a wildly unexpected successful campaign that is likely an outlier. Listen to the hockey minds that you hired.
There’s also an element of “you make your own luck” in these scenarios…..and we’ve certainly seen that here over the last decade.
THIS! Benning's decisions are best understood by understanding his incentives and understanding his understanding of the owners' incentives. Rikster's not making a normative claim here, just providing insight into what motivates decisions.rikster wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:54 pm Why would a GM try to sell an owner on being a bad hockey team for years knowing that the chances that he will stick around to finish the job are almost zero?
Why would an owner, who by defination is a control freak and use to making money, sign off on a plan that hurts his bottom line and the prestige amongst his peers?
I just don't see evidence of this being the "average" result, unless you are measuring from the lowest ebb, which by definition has improvements. For every Montreal there is a Buffalo. And comparatively? With average luck, the Canucks were in the playoffs 5 years into the Benning era "re-tool" -- and with the stuff that *could* have been sustainable but for decisions made then and after -- bad decisions that still didn't permanently shitcan the whole project, and left the next group with stuff to succeed or fail with. (They failed).Ronning's Ghost wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:55 pm At least with a re-build, with minimally competent management, and just average luck, four to five seasons later, you should be stronger than when you went in.
I meant better than when you decided you needed to re-tool or rebuild. Addressing this would take more scholarship than I am willing to undertake at the moment; the sample size is huge, and we'd need to agree on standards for "minimally competent" and "average luck". But using just the Canucks from that period as an example...UWSaint wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:02 pmI just don't see evidence of this being the "average" result, unless you are measuring from the lowest ebb, which by definition has improvements.Ronning's Ghost wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:55 pm At least with a re-build, with minimally competent management, and just average luck, four to five seasons later, you should be stronger than when you went in.
Assuming that what the Canucks experienced was average luck, imagine -- as I supposed above -- taking those results, but minus every trade and free agent signing that was made with a view to a quick return to competitiveness, or even being competitive any time from 2014 to 2018, and instead having all of those trades (and more especially, non-trades) and signings focussed on being the best team they could be in 2019, and I have to expect that the 2019 product would have been better.