Grabner already through to Main Camp
Moderator: Referees
Grabner already through to Main Camp
http://www.canucks.com/theinsider/defau ... =5&id=1592
Just saw this on the canucks website, actually a pretty good day-to-day camp update there.
Thoughts? Is this surprising to anyone else?
Just saw this on the canucks website, actually a pretty good day-to-day camp update there.
Thoughts? Is this surprising to anyone else?
-
- CC 2nd Team All-Star
- Posts: 406
- Joined: Fri Sep 08, 2006 10:21 pm
- Location: Surrey, BC
Doesn't surprise me none. He was their first round pick (I actually booed him when they announced his name) and they're going to want to see how he stacks up compared to what we currently have. He wont make the team and will be sent back down to Spokane for more seasoning, but it'll be a good experience for him.
-
- CC 2nd Team All-Star
- Posts: 406
- Joined: Fri Sep 08, 2006 10:21 pm
- Location: Surrey, BC
Quite honestly I think he'll be another 1st round bust. I just dont see enough talent in him to be the NHL game breaker that some people expect him to be. He'll be another Josh Holden.gobi wrote:I am happy for Grabner. I think this will be a good experience for him. I am sure he won't make the team but it should give him more confidence and motivation to improve his game. I hope to see him with the club in one or two years.
- Meerschaum
- MVP
- Posts: 492
- Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2004 5:50 pm
- Location: Vancouver, B.C.
Whoa, way too early to be judging the guy. He is a late '87 birthdate, and will take some seasoning before a real assessment can be made.The_Pauser wrote:Quite honestly I think he'll be another 1st round bust. I just dont see enough talent in him to be the NHL game breaker that some people expect him to be. He'll be another Josh Holden.gobi wrote:I am happy for Grabner. I think this will be a good experience for him. I am sure he won't make the team but it should give him more confidence and motivation to improve his game. I hope to see him with the club in one or two years.
As well, for a guy who was projecting Bernier as a good sleeper pick to play with the Sedins, I am not too sure how much stalk to put into your ideas around Grabner...
"We Will Rise Again"
- Fan's sign from the final game of the 05/06 season
- Fan's sign from the final game of the 05/06 season
-
- CC Rookie
- Posts: 25
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 11:10 am
- Location: Toronto, Ontario
he won't get signed, and won't be playing in the NHL this year.hench wrote:Grabner will be tested and played in the NHL this year. Whether he stays there will depend on how he does...obviously. He seems to be a goal scorer...so maybe hed fit in with the sedins, but again, depends on how he does against the pros.
for one thing, the canucks can't afford to add a rookie max contract to the payroll... and 2ndly, he's not NHL ready at all to even bother signing him.
He was invited to main camp because he's a 1st round pick... he could have stunk out the joint in the rookie camp, and would still head to main camp... no surprise at all.
I don't think we'll see Grabner in the NHL barring a major injury bug to our offensive guys, who frankly can't be replaced by the likes of Mike Brown and Rick Rypien, even then, he'd have to demonstrate that he was developing fast enough to step in without it being a waste of anyone's time. I don't think we'll want to start burning up our RFA time with him, regardless if that means less with Booby Clarke.
I think Grabner is exactly what the Canucks said he was going to be, high risk or high reward...he'll either be a star offensive player, or he'll be Harold Druken, but we can't predict that now, and I'm happier with this given that we NEED offensive guys, as good as Kesler was, I was a bit distraught when we used our draft pick that year (which was DEEP) to go with Kesler, only for Burke to announce he was a "safe" pick, would definitely make it to the NHL and soon, but have an upside as an "elite third liner"... Those guys are easier to replace than the gifted goal scorers, so you take your risks when you go after them, it takes balls but that's what it takes to win.
I think Grabner is exactly what the Canucks said he was going to be, high risk or high reward...he'll either be a star offensive player, or he'll be Harold Druken, but we can't predict that now, and I'm happier with this given that we NEED offensive guys, as good as Kesler was, I was a bit distraught when we used our draft pick that year (which was DEEP) to go with Kesler, only for Burke to announce he was a "safe" pick, would definitely make it to the NHL and soon, but have an upside as an "elite third liner"... Those guys are easier to replace than the gifted goal scorers, so you take your risks when you go after them, it takes balls but that's what it takes to win.
Mark