Topper wrote:HW, MG replaced a streaky scoring Samuelson with a streaky scoring booth.
Adding Paulson was a no brainer.
Ask yourself, where would Cody be playing in today's line up, he showed he cannot play wing and he is such a defensive liability could he handle any of the King's top three lines. Not a chance.
Like I said I liked the Booth trade and I think he can turn it around and next season. But I wonder whether trading Raymond instead of Samuelsson would have been a better idea. I wouldn't undo the trade if the piece that went to Florida still had to be Samuelsson.
I have no problem with the Pahlson trade.
But I am second guessing the Hodgson move. Not so much that he was traded but what he was traded for.
What I lament the most is that our top six are not top six. Last year they played like it this year they could not. I don't think Hodgson was the answer either. Thats why I advocate a change. Keep the Sedins and Burrows together, drop Kesler to 3rd line and create an offensive line with that other rookie down the middle.
I would rather be the Canucks that most other teams. I think we are still very competitive in the West and will make the playoffs next year as well. I think we can still contend for the cup but I see the holes. Same holes most of us talked about in the off season.
1) a true number one D'man
2) another true top six forward
3) A big strong forward who can play 10-15 minutes a night and be a real deterrent.
MG may have filled one of those in Kassian but he isn't there yet buy any stretch. I'm more than prepared to give him time but how he shows up to camp will speak volumes.
What MG could not address was top D'man. He though he was addressing a top 6 in Booth and for a while it looked like maybe he had then the injury hit. If Booth can rediscover his scoring touch then fine. Kesler and Booth should not be on the same line. Booth in particular needs a set up guy. Maybe he would be better suited with the twins next year and maybe he needs a longer look see there.
The biggest need I see for next year is a 2nd line centre with offensive potential. Maybe we have that in the system and hopefully time will tell.
As for trades. Ya, If Luongo will waive to go to Tampa I think we could get a nice return. His cap is only 5.3 but coming off the books would help in trying to land a FA.
Like everyone, well almost everyone, I am disappointed and a little surprised. But I don't feel the disappointment I felt last year. I still think we have a solid core to build around.