Moderator: Referees
CorranHorn wrote:Here are the penalties from the Pit/Phi game.
1st Period
NONE
2nd period
03:04 PHI Claude Giroux: Boarding-2 min
10:06 PHI Zac Rinaldo : Cross Checking - 2 min
3rd Period
01:49 PHI JAGS: Interference-2 min
10:41 PIT Brooks Orpik: Interference - 2 min
OT Period
NONE
Of the three which was the most entertaining... and WHY?!
I'm sure the irony is not lost on most of us here, however, it would at least be nice to know which way they are going to call things. Last night's pattern in 2 of the 3 games was totally different than even the last 3 weeks of the regular season.Benjo wrote:Last season many Canuck fans and posters on this board were up in arms that the NHL changed the rules for the playoffs and were calling nothing, now in this thread I'm reading the refs should have just let the players sort it out. We can't have it both ways at our convenience.
Agreed. If there's any one thing that really should alienate the Canucks to the rest of the fans of the league it's this stuff. Every time a Canuck dives, I feel a little embarrassed to be a fan.Benjo wrote:Kesler stop diving...just...enough already jesus. That somersault in the neutral zone was ridiculous.
Larry Goodenough wrote:My main point is reffing games with integrity. If snowing a goalie is a penalty, call it every time. Don't change the rules to suit the situation.
Put me down for NOT like. Of course it leads to chaos if you link the suspension to the injury: 4th-line-scrub X smashes super-star-Y and we don't see either for the rest of the playoffs. Who loses in that trade-off?herb wrote:Like it or not, Shanahan has made it clear that he bases his suspensions on the severity of the injury to the player the offending play occurred on.
Fred wrote:If a minor snowing by Kesler called unsportsman how come in every scrum there's half the players giving face washes to each other ? is that sportsmanship.
mathonwy wrote:Fred wrote:If a minor snowing by Kesler called unsportsman how come in every scrum there's half the players giving face washes to each other ? is that sportsmanship.
I actually agree with this call. Snowing the goalie is THE best way for a player to piss off the entire team and its amazingly easy to do.
You let one go, and then Luo gets snowed and you gotta let that one go. And then it escalates pretty fast after that.
Face washes are just typically 1on1 scrums. Snowing (or anything) the goaltender becomes 5on5 scrums.
RoyalDude wrote:Smell the coffee, mathonwy. This team is highly overrated. It's how I've felt all year about them, sorry if this doesn't sit all that well with you. Gillis has a sinking ship on his hands.

mathonwy wrote:Fred wrote:If a minor snowing by Kesler called unsportsman how come in every scrum there's half the players giving face washes to each other ? is that sportsmanship.
I actually agree with this call. Snowing the goalie is THE best way for a player to piss off the entire team and its amazingly easy to do.
You let one go, and then Luo gets snowed and you gotta let that one go. And then it escalates pretty fast after that.
Face washes are just typically 1on1 scrums. Snowing (or anything) the goaltender becomes 5on5 scrums.
Strangelove wrote:mathonwy wrote:Fred wrote:If a minor snowing by Kesler called unsportsman how come in every scrum there's half the players giving face washes to each other ? is that sportsmanship.
I actually agree with this call. Snowing the goalie is THE best way for a player to piss off the entire team and its amazingly easy to do.
You let one go, and then Luo gets snowed and you gotta let that one go. And then it escalates pretty fast after that.
Face washes are just typically 1on1 scrums. Snowing (or anything) the goaltender becomes 5on5 scrums.
Does anyone think the fact Kess got away with bumping Quick, resulting in a goal, 8 minutes previous had anything to do with it?
coco_canuck wrote:Just remember, it's game 1.

Fred wrote:mathonwy wrote:Fred wrote:If a minor snowing by Kesler called unsportsman how come in every scrum there's half the players giving face washes to each other ? is that sportsmanship.
I actually agree with this call. Snowing the goalie is THE best way for a player to piss off the entire team and its amazingly easy to do.
You let one go, and then Luo gets snowed and you gotta let that one go. And then it escalates pretty fast after that.
Face washes are just typically 1on1 scrums. Snowing (or anything) the goaltender becomes 5on5 scrums.
Who knows, the rule is called unsportsmanship...heck I just assumed that's what it meant. Tell you what how many times is that same action resulting in nothing being called, so why this ref and why not the others. I'm picking on one thing but really every game is an adventure. I certainly have no iodea what's going to be called and what's not going to be called. AND THEN the third period you could have got away with 3rd degree man slaughter. It just doesn't make sense any more. Weber gets a $2500 fine for punching a guys head into the boards. Rome gets 4 games after a guy admires his pass. Clifford nothing for driving Tanevs haed into the board, Keith gets a minor for elbowing Sedin in the head....on and on and on. It gets tougher and tougher to justify following hockey and paying out great wads of moeny
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests