I Cannot Believe it is a Suspension Thread

[Jovocop]

Wow, only two games for Hall's nasty knee-on-knee hit but one game suspension for Hansen... ClutterBUG is only crutches while Mary only missed one period. What kind of message is Shanny sending to all the players??

http://www.tsn.ca/nhl/story/?id=416614

Edmonton Oilers forward Taylor Hall has been suspended two games for kneeing Minnesota Wild forward Cal Clutterbuck during Thursday's game.

Hall appeared to deliver a knee-on-knee hit to Clutterbuck, who had to be helped off the ice and didn't return to the game.

Hall received a five-minute kneeing penalty as well as a 10-minute and game misconduct penalty for the hit, which came with under three minutes left in the third period of Edmonton's 3-1 home loss to the Wild.

Wild head coach Mike Yeo said on Friday that Clutterbuck suffered a thigh contusion and the injured forward was seen walking on crutches.

Clutterbuck also stated that he thought Hall's hit was reckless.

This is Hall's first NHL suspension.

[Strangelove]

Fans all around the league are laughing at the NHL Safety Committee.

If you are reading this Shanny: Wake up buddy, they've made you into their circus clown.

[Hockey Widow]

I think Shanny is saying if you are a star player two things:

If you are the offender, you get off light.
If you are the victim your injured party will get a heavy suspension.


I really think he weights theses decisions based upon the players stay=us in the league.

Lets see, Horton is better than Rome so Rome is gone. Keith, Sedin, Keith, Sedin, toss up.

Hossa/Hansen, suspend the dude (not you RD)

Hall, Clutterfick....minimal suspension.

Oh wiat, that doesn't work with Cooke though does it. Or Crosby.

Maybe it really is a team thing.

Oh hell I don't know, does Shanny even know?

[Meds]

Oh hell I don't know, does Shanny even know?

BS is putting some serious BS out there right now.

I think he's a puppet. Just a popular former player who is being used for his face in hopes that fans and dumbass, know nothing US analysts don't bitch so much because they figure a guy like Shannahan knows what's right on the ice.....

[Hockey Widow]

I'm still waiting for him to suspend himself for his crosscheck to Morrison's face that cost Morrison a few teeth.

[dangler]

The video replay pretty much tells the tale for me.
puck is flicked into the air,hansen reaches up to glove the puck, at the same time hossa is skating backwards,watching the puck,moving towards the area the puck will land,when hansen realizes they are going to collide, he lowers his arm to protect himself from the ensuing collision.
absolutely incidental, no question
I like to think this unbiased, but Maybe i am looking at it through canuck-coloured-glasses as it seems many who have seen the same replay seem to think it was a intentional elbow

I CANNOT BELIEVE IT IS A SUSPENSION!!!

[Topper]

Shanny the media whore tries ducking the spotlight.

http://www.nhl.com/ice/news.htm?id=656884&navid=nhl:topheads

[Aaronp18]

I think AV has been leasing out his coin.

[tantalum]

For goodness sakes NHL just set lower and upper boundaries on suspensions and let independent arbitrators knowledgeable in the game levy the suspension. Time to get the discipline away from the central office.

[Reefer2]

And Hossa did not miss a game, over 17 mins in Friday's game.

[BurningBeard]

For goodness sakes NHL just set lower and upper boundaries on suspensions and let independent arbitrators knowledgeable in the game levy the suspension. Time to get the discipline away from the central office.

I've been wondering this for awhile myself. For the life of me I don't understand why they let one person make this decision. It invites continued analysis and criticism, which only gets worst over time. It should either be done by an independent arbitrator, or an independent arbitrator in conjunction with a NHLPA representative and NHL representative (like a panel). That way central office still has their say.

[Hockey Widow]

Clowe gets two games for starting an altercation after leaving the bench. Upon further video review the league determined he left the bench on a legal line change, not an illegal one, therefore the 10 game automatic suspension did not apply.

[dbr]

Alex Edler has a hearing with the NHL for this hit:


(Credit to HFBoards poster Lucbourdon for the .gif)

[Cornuck]

Maybe if the kid (a) kept his head up and (b) learned how to fasten his helmet, we wouldn't be having this discussion.

What a joke. No intent + No injury = suspension.

[The Brown Knight]

Since a Canuck made the hit, I expect somewhere between 5-10 games.